While the Champions League and Premier League bring bright lights, big money, and eternal glory, the FA Cup will always hold a special place in the heart of English football. Not only is the iconic cup competition the oldest in the country, but it also happens to be the oldest national football tournament in the world. The FA Cup has been played almost every single year since its inception in the 1871/72 campaign, and almost 150 finals have taken place in that period. But what is the best FA Cup final of all time?
Top Five FA Cup Finals of All Time
For the purposes of this top five list, we have taken into account a combination of electric drama, iconic moments, cultural impact, and lasting legacy.
5) 1981 – Tottenham Hotspur 3-2 Manchester City
We were hesitant to put any FA Cup replays into this top five, but there is one exception to the rule: 1981. For those who aren’t aware, finals used to be replayed in the event of a draw before the year 2000, when the rule was finally scrapped (and with good reason!) So, when the 100th FA Cup final ended 1-1 between Spurs and Man City, the two sides had to go again five days later.
It was an eventful first final for Tommy Hutchinson, who managed to score at both ends of the pitch for Man City, but he kept his place for the second showdown. However, this time, it was Steve Perryman, Glenn Hoddle, Ossie Ardiles, and the FA Cup icon Ricky Villa who stole the show. After Villa put Spurs 1-0 up with eight on the clock, Steve MacKenzie drew the Citizens level just three minutes later. Man City then took the lead in the 50th minute thanks to Kevin Reeves, before Garth Crooks netted an equaliser in the 70th. Cue one of the greatest FA Cup goals of all time…
Ricky Villa slalomed, chopped, and turned his way past four Man City defenders before slotting the ball past Joe Corrigan in net, sending North London into pandemonium. Not only had Villa won Spurs their first of two FA Cups on the bounce, but his solo effort was also named the Wembley Goal of the Century. Even the match itself was dubbed the ‘match of the century’ at the time!
While Manchester United’s 3-3 draw with Crystal Palace in 1990 is almost a worthy inclusion on this list, the fact that the final was actually decided by a 1-0 replay kind of sucks out the joy.
4) 1987 – Coventry City 3-2 Tottenham Hotspur
From winners to losers, it was Spurs on the wrong end of an iconic final in 1987. The Lilywhites came into the final as favourites after falling short in a title race with Everton and Liverpool, while Coventry City finished down in 10th in the First Division. With seven FA Cups under their belt to Coventry’s zero, it certainly felt like a case of David vs Goliath.
Tottenham actually took the lead in the second minute through Clive Allen before Dave Bennett equalised seven minutes later. Spurs took the lead for a second time, thanks to a 41st-minute Gary Mabbutt goal, but Cov came back for a second time to force extra-time via Keith Houchen. Unfortunately for Mabbutt, it was a hero-to-zero storyline as his 96th-minute own goal settled the tie in Coventry’s favour.
Iconic BBC commentator John Motson then dropped the famous line: "This is the finest cup final I've had the pleasure of commentating on.”
Weirdly, despite appearing in nine FA Cup finals, this is the only one Tottenham have ever lost. Spurs went on to win a then-record eighth FA Cup in 1991.
3) 2006 – Liverpool 3-3 West Ham United
Despite being heavy favourites in 2006 after lifting the Champions League one year prior, Liverpool pulled off one of the greatest-ever FA Cup comebacks at the dismay of West Ham United.
A Jamie Carragher own goal (of course) kicked things off in the 21st minute before West Ham stunned Liverpool by doubling their lead seven minutes later through Dean Ashton. Unfortunately for the Hammers, the reigning champions of Europe were well-used to coming from behind to steal major silverware. Djibril Cisse ensured that Liverpool were only two down for a matter of minutes before Steven Gerrard levelled the scores on 54. But the final took another nightmare turn for the Reds when Paul Konchesky’s cross looped all the way in at the far post to retake the lead for the East London side. As the clock ticked into injury time, it looked to be a famous day for West Ham United. Arise, Steven Gerrard…
When the Hammers cleared a Riise cross in the 91st minute to relative safety, no one counted on Liverpool’s captain to rifle a 35-yard volley into the bottom corner to force a shock extra-time. The game ended up going all the way to penalties, where Harmann, Gerrard and Riise scored, while Zamora, Konchesky, and Ferdinand missed. For obvious reasons, this is widely known as “The Gerrard Final”.
2) 2013 – Wigan 1-0 Manchester City
Few people gave Wigan Athletic any chance back in 2013, even the most optimistic of Latics fans. This was Man City after the money. This was Man City after breaking their FA Cup drought in 2011. This was Man City with Sergio Aguero, Yaya Toure, Vincent Kompany, and Carlos Tevez. Perhaps even more importantly, this was relegation-threatened Wigan.
Yet despite all that, Wigan kept the Citizens at bay. 14 shots to Man City’s 15. 48% possession to Roberto Mancini’s 52%. City may have knocked on the door a little harder than their opponents, with 12 shots on target to six, but it was hardly a May evening whitewash. But as the game ticked towards what seemed like an inevitable 0-0 full-time whistle, and another 30 minutes to come, everything changed.
On 84 minutes, Pablo Zabaleta was handed his marching orders after picking up a second yellow card. Buoyed by the prospect of spending extra time as the dominant force, even Wigan took themselves by surprise in the 91st minute when a Shaun Maloney corner was nodded home by Ben Watson.
To put the true nature of the underdog story into perspective, Wigan went on to be relegated a matter of weeks later, and 2013 remains their only-ever taste of FA Cup glory. We love a cupset!
1) 1953 – Blackpool 4-3 Bolton Wanderers
There aren’t too many finals that receive their own nickname, let alone one that is still known across the world 70 years later. But that’s exactly what happened with Stanley Matthews in 1953. Despite being one of England’s greatest-ever players (some would argue the greatest at the time), Matthews had only ever lifted a smattering of minor trophies. A Second Division title here, a Glasgow Charity Cup there; it was hardly the trophy cabinet of an all-time legend of the sport.
At age 38, you could have forgiven old Stanley for fearing the worst, too. After all, he had already lost the 1948 and 1951 FA Cup finals in the orange of Blackpool. Fortunately for Matthews, it was a classic case of third time lucky.
Although Sam Mortensen scored a rare FA Cup final hat-trick, it was Matthews who grabbed the headlines as the star of the show. The Wizard of the Dribble put in one of his most iconic performances and finally tasted a major silverware victory before his 40th birthday. While Blackpool took great joy in holding the FA Cup trophy aloft, Matthews’ teammates also hoisted the man himself into the air for one of football’s most iconic photographs. How foolish the naysayers would have looked as well, as 38-year-old Stanley went on to play another 12 years at the top!
Even if you put all the Stanley Matthews stuff to one side, this remains one of the most exciting and highest-scoring finals of all time. But 1953 is and forever will be known as the Matthews final.
The Biggest FA Cup Winners
We know all about the iconic finals from the yesteryears of FA Cup history books, but what about the most successful teams? Arsenal lead the way with an astounding 14 FA Cups to their name, with Man United in close attendance on 13. Giants of old, Tottenham, have been stuck on eight since 1991.
| Club | FA Cup wins | Runners-up |
| Arsenal | 14 | 7 |
| Man United | 13 | 9 |
| Chelsea | 8 | 8 |
| Liverpool | 8 | 7 |
| Tottenham | 8 | 1 |
| Man City | 7 | 7 |
| Aston Villa | 7 | 4 |
| Newcastle United | 6 | 7 |
| Blackburn Rovers | 6 | 2 |
In terms of the most dominant periods of FA Cup glory. Only two teams have even lifted three trophies in a row. Wanderers achieved the feat in 1876-78, but the club dissolved by 1887. Blackburn Rovers equalled the record from 1884-86, but it hasn’t been done since. Plenty of clubs have gone back-to-back, including Wanderers, Blackburn, Newcastle, Tottenham, Arsenal, and Chelsea.
