The Ballon d’Or is seen as the most prestigious individual honour a footballer can win in their career, beyond the team goals of Champions League titles and World Cups. Lifting the Ballon d’Or sends a clear message – ‘I am the greatest player in the world’. Only a select few legends of the game ever taste the uppermost echelon of football awards, with such names including Zinedine Zidane, Johan Cruyff, Michel Platini, Cristiano Ronaldo, and Lionel Messi. But what about the historic battles of the Ballon d’Or? For every winner, there is someone who narrowly misses out on the iconic golden ball. Sometimes, it’s a tale of David vs Goliath, while other times it’s a straight heavyweight bout for the title. Without further ado, let the Ballon d’Or battles commence!
The most historic Ballon d’Or football rivalries of all time
Lionel Messi vs Cristiano Ronaldo Ballon d’Or
Where else could we possibly start? Lionel Messi vs Cristiano Ronaldo was a generational rivalry in a football-defining era. To this day, people still argue over which of the two holds the ultimate GOAT status. Although the Ballon d’Or was always seen as a prestigious award long before Messi or Ronaldo were even born, their decade-long fight for bragging rights propelled it to new heights. It was no longer a question of which footballer would be deemed the best that year, but which of Messi and Ronaldo would add to their tally.
If we are going on numbers alone, then it is clear that the Argentine won that particular battle. Messi holds a record eight Ballon d’Or awards to his name, with Ronaldo coming in second on five. To put that into context, the next highest total is just three (Platini, Cruyff, and Van Basten). Cristiano Ronaldo recorded his five wins in 2008, 2013, 2014, 2016, and 2017, and Lionel Messi’s five second-place finishes just so happened to fall on the same years. Fortunately for the Barcelona legend, he lifted eight of his own in 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012, 2015, 2019, 2021, and 2023.
One of the pair’s most famous Ballon d’Or battles came back in the calendar year of 2012. Cristiano Ronaldo scored 63 goals that year, leading Real Madrid to yet another La Liga title. His tally was the fourth highest in football history. There was just one problem… Lionel Messi scored 91. That’s right, ninety-one goals in a single year! Suffice it to say, that is an all-time record and 6 more than anyone else has ever achieved. Despite Ronaldo’s 2012 success, Messi took 41.6% of the votes and claimed his fourth Ballon d’Or.
In 2013, Ronaldo and Messi had their closest-ever Ballon d'Or battle, with the Portugal star taking 27.99% of the votes compared to the Argentine’s 24.72%. Ronaldo had managed to surpass his incredible 2012 tally by recording the joint-fifth-highest goalscoring year of all-time – 69 goals in all competitions. Messi managed just 45 – pathetic. In 2016, the numbers were close once more, with Messi ending the year with 59 goals and 31 assists in 62 games compared to Ronaldo’s 55 goals and 16 assists in 57 matches. Ronaldo lifted both the Champions League and the prestigious Golden Ball that year.
If Ronaldo is looking to claw some bragging rights back, then he at least has the record for the most Ballon d’Or nominations with 18, two more than Messi’s career 16. When the last 10 Ballon d'Or winners were asked to settle the Messi vs Ronaldo debate, three chose Cristiano (Zinedine Zidane, Michael Owen, and Karim Benzema), while seven selected the diminutive Argentine (including Rodri, Ronaldo, Luka Modric, and Ronaldinho). Whatever the case, Messi and Ronaldo are the two undisputed Ballon d’Or legends and forged one of football’s greatest rivalries.
Johan Cruyff vs Franz Beckenbauer
Before Cristiano Ronaldo and Lionel Messi were even wearing diapers, Johan Cruyff and Franz Beckenbauer gave birth to the original Ballon d’Or rivalry. Let us cast our minds back to the European football landscape of the 1970s. Back then, you didn’t have to play for a team in one of the so-called ‘Big Five’ leagues to get your hands on the Footballer of the Year trophy. Florian Albert won it with Ferencvaros in 1967, Oleg Blokhin with Dynamo Kyiv in 1975, and famously Johan Cruyff with Ajax in 1971. The Dutch football icon scored 27 and 33 goals for Ajax in the 1970/71 and 1971/72 seasons respectively, while also winning the Eredivisie and European Cup in 1971.
Fast forward to 1972, and Franz Beckenbauer announced himself on the Ballon d’Or stage, beating Gerd Muller and Gunter Netzer in a German-heavy top three. This was largely thanks to Bayern Munich’s Bundesliga victory and Germany’s European Championship win in 1972, with Beckenbauer playing at the heart of both teams.
In 1973, Cruyff was back again, this time in the colours of Barcelona following his transfer from Ajax. In fact, Cruyff lifted another European Cup with the Dutch side in the first half of 1973, before moving to Barca and starting a La Liga title charge. He ended up scoring 24 and 14 for Barcelona between 1973 and 1975.
In 1974, Cruyff and Beckenbauer finally appeared in the top two together, with the Dutchman claiming the award and the German coming in second. There were just 11 points between them that year (116 for Cruyff and 105 for Beckenbauer). Beckenbauer won both the Bundesliga and World Cup in 1974, but it wasn’t enough to beat Cruyff with his La Liga title and World Cup runners-up medal. That’s right, they even went head-to-head in the World Cup final!
In 1975, Cruyff and Beckenbauer were neck and neck once more in the Ballon d’Or rankings but, unfortunately for them, it was in second and third as Oleg Blokhin lifted the trophy. That was the last time we saw Johan Cruyff in the top three, but Beckenbauer still had one more Ballon d’Or victory in the locker in 1976. That left the Dutchman on three and the German on two.
Closest Ballon d’Or race of all-time
In 1966, Bobby Charlton lifted the World Cup with England – his country’s only ever victory in the competition to this day. He also went on to win the Football League First Division with Manchester United in the 1966/67 campaign. While you would think the World Cup winner would walk to a Ballon d’Or title, that wasn’t the case. Portuguese legend, Eusebio, finished just one point behind Charlton in the standings thanks to his form with Benfica and a third-place finish at the World Cup with Portugal. To this day, it is the tightest Ballon d’Or race of all time.
Matthias Sammer and Ronaldo Nazario didn’t enjoy a long and storied battle throughout their careers, but they did make history in the 1996 Ballon d’Or race. Sammer lifted the Bundesliga title with Borussia Dortmund in 1996, as well as the DFL-Supercup and the European Championship trophy with Germany. He even went on to win the Champions League in the 1996/97 season with Dortmund. Ronaldo, meanwhile, won the KNVB Cup with PSV Eindhoven in 1996 before making a move to Barcelona in the summer and winning an Olympic bronze medal with Brazil U23s. What linked these two players was the closest-ever Ballon d’Or race in history, with Sammer claiming the win with 144 points and Ronaldo finishing just one behind with 143. The ironic thing is that the totals have since changed, with Ronaldo actually finishing on 141. This is because Northern Ireland’s votes were counted backwards – first was mistakenly counted as fifth, second as fourth, and so on.
Famous Ballon d’Or face-offs
Lionel Messi vs Virgil Van Dijk
Of course, Lionel Messi and Virgil Van Dijk are not intrinsically linked on the football pitch like Ronaldo and Messi, but they did take part in one of the most controversial Ballon d’Or moments of all time. Van Dijk led Liverpool to a Champions League title, Super Cup, and Club World Cup in 2019, and eventually went on to win the Premier League in the 2019/20 season too. He was named the Premier League Player of the Season for 2018/19, the PFA Player’s Player of the Year, and made the PFA Team of the Year. Many assumed this made him a shoo-in for the Ballon d’Or. Messi won La Liga with Barcelona and scored 50 goals in 58 games in 2019, but many still believe he robbed the award from Liverpool’s captain. It was Lionel Messi’s slimmest-ever Ballon d’Or win, pipping Van Dijk by just seven points (686 vs 679).
Rodri vs Vinicius Jr.
Talking of controversial Ballon d’Or victories, let’s take a look at 2024. For a long time, people assumed Vinicius Jr. was guaranteed to win the award – or at least that’s what Real Madrid wanted people to think. A La Liga and Champions League victory was certainly impressive, and the Brazilian had scored a bunch of goals on the route to both of those victories. He managed 24 goals and 11 assists in 39 games across all competitions for Real Madrid in 2023/24, as well as another two at Copa America for Brazil. However, it was ultimately his failure to lift the Copa America trophy with his national side that likely cost him in the Ballon d’Or vote. Despite playing holding midfield, Rodri registered 9 goals and 14 assists for Man City in the 2023/24 season – not that far behind Vinicius’ numbers as a forward. Rodri also lifted a record fourth Premier League trophy in a row, and was part of the European Championship-winning Spain side, even scoring once at the finals. In the end, this was enough to see him beat Vinicius Jr. to the award, 1170 points to 1129. Real Madrid certainly took the news graciously, lashing out at the Ballon d’Or ceremony by refusing to attend.
Kylian Mbappe vs Erling Haaland – Future Ballon d’Or winners?
The big question for the Ballon d’Or in 2024/25 is… what’s next? Many football fans have selected Kylian Mbappe and Erling Haaland as the heirs to the Messi vs Ronaldo rivalry. They are certainly the two biggest names in modern-day football, and it helps that they both play similar positions up front for Real Madrid and Man City respectively. However, both are yet to win their first Ballon d'Or award. The closest they came was in 2023 when Haaland finished second and Mbappe third, rather controversially as Lionel Messi was given his eighth Ballon d’Or despite his famous World Cup win falling outside of the voting parameters. It seems unlikely that either Mbappe or Haaland will ever match the success of Messi and Ronaldo in this particular individual competition, but they could, at the very least, create the third long-term rivalry the Ballon d’Or has ever seen. Johan Cruyff vs Franz Beckenbauer. Lionel Messi vs Cristiano Ronaldo. Erling Haaland vs Kylian Mbappe? All we need now is for Haaland to move to Barcelona to really run it back!
