Ranking the 10 Worst VAR Mistakes in Premier League History 

Referee Paul Tierney checks the VAR screen during the Premier League match between Tottenham Hotspur and Liverpool at the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium in 2021. (Photo by AP Photo/Frank Augstein)

At the start of the 2019/20 season, something game-changing happened in the Premier League as Video Assistant Refereeing rolled out across 380 games. The state-of-the-art technology was designed to finally remove the most controversial moments from the beautiful game – false offside calls, referee mistakes, and incidents only an action replay could decipher. There was just one problem; VAR itself arrived full of mistakes of its own. Not only did the technology take an age to use, but referees were still somehow coming to the wrong conclusions despite having unlimited slow-motion replays and multiple angles at their disposal. Let’s take a look through the top 10 worst VAR decisions in Premier League history. 

10) Nottingham Forest 1-1 Brentford: October 2023 

When even the goalkeeper admits he was worried VAR was going to intervene, you know the on-pitch decision was probably a little unjust. That’s exactly what happened when Matt Turner blatantly fouled Yoane Wissa in the box when Brentford visited Nottingham Forest in October 2023. The referee waved play-on and the VAR chose not to get involved, much to the relief of Turner. 

He said after the game: "I was a little bit worried, but I tried to hold back as much as I could because I knew he was going to win it. I’m glad VAR didn’t intervene because that would have made things go from bad to worse for me.” 

9) Everton 2-2 Liverpool: October 2020 

This one really depends on which team you support. When Everton goalkeeper Jordan Pickford went crunching into a wild challenge on Virgil Van Dijk in his own penalty area, it looked like the Toffees could be in trouble. However, Pickford and Everton were saved by the offside flag, which was then confirmed by the Premier League VAR. Despite this preventing a Liverpool penalty, there were still calls for Pickford to be shown a red card. Van Dijk was withdrawn from the game and ended up missing most of the rest of the season with an ACL injury. Despite these calls, Pickford remained on the pitch, Everton earned a draw, and no retrospective suspension was handed to him. 

8) Manchester United 1-1 Liverpool: October 2020 

Man United vs Liverpool is always an aggressive and passionate affair, but many believed that Victor Lindelof got away with one in October 2020. When the ball was played into Liverpool’s Divock Origi mid-way into United’s half, Lindelof appeared to chop his legs away. However, when the referee waved play-on, the Red Devils took full advantage and went down the other end to score through Marcus Rashford. The VAR reviewed the decision but came to the conclusion that it was not a clear and obvious mistake by the referee and, therefore, the goal stood. Liverpool went on to fight back and earn a draw and went on to win the title by a landslide, so the consequences of the mishap weren’t too grievous in hindsight. 

7) Chelsea 2-2 Tottenham: August 2022 

Cristian Romero appeared to showcase one of the most obvious calls for a red card during the London derby between Chelsea and Tottenham in August 2022. When a corner was curled into the box, Romero decided to give himself an edge by pulling Marc Cucurella back by his iconic long curls. It turns out, hair-pulling is not specifically mentioned in the laws of the game. One would have assumed that the on-field referee or VAR would use their common sense, but the incident was reviewed and cleared. Tottenham ended up earning a rare draw at Stamford Bridge. 

6) Fulham 3-2 Wolves: November 2023 

One of the best uses of VAR is to view slow-motion replays to see whether defenders got a touch on the ball before their attacking counterparts. That is exactly what happened in November 2023 in Fulham vs Wolves when referee Michael Salisbury pointed to the spot following a challenge from Nelson Semedo. However, the replays clearly showed that Semedo got a slight touch on the ball before taking down Tom Cairney. Unfortunately, the Premier League VAR did not agree, and the penalty was upheld, with William scoring to make it 2-1. Wolves lost the game 3-2 and eventually finished just one point behind Fulham in the table, missing out on some extra prize money. VAR mistakes can be very costly! 

5) Everton 0-1 Manchester City: February 2022 

Frank Lampard’s furious post-match quotes tell you everything you need to know about this VAR mistake: "A three-year-old could tell you that is a penalty.” In February 2022, as Man City pushed for the title and Everton fought to avoid relegation, Rodri did his best Ederson impression and clearly handled the ball inside his own box. Not only did the referee miss it, but the VAR cleared Rodri of any wrongdoing. A penalty could have earned the Toffees a vital point in the relegation battle, while Liverpool finished just one point behind Man City in the Premier League title race that season. 

4) Manchester United 1-0 Wolves: August 2023 

If the VARs wanted to keep their heads down at the start of the 2023/24 season, they didn’t do a very good job. The Red Devils were 1-0 up at home to Wolves in August when the Wanderers looked to have an obvious route back into the match from the penalty spot. There was just one problem, the penalty was not given. When Sasa Kalajdzic was absolutely flattened by Andre Onana, the on-pitch referee believed the goalkeeper got a touch on the ball. Somehow, VAR checked the incident and cleared it, despite Onana clearly not getting a touch. PGMOL had to issue an apology and acknowledge their mistake later that evening. 

3) Arsenal 1-1 B rentford: February 2023 

In February 2023, as Arsenal pushed for the Premier League title, VAR made the most unforgivable sin. After the Gunners took the lead against Brentford through Leandro Trossard, it looked like they stood a chance of picking up another vital three points. When Ivan Toney eventually equalised for the Bees, Arsenal players appealed for an offside – and rightly so. Replays showed that Toney was indeed well off, but the VAR on the day – Lee Mason – simply forgot to draw the lines on the monitor to check the decision properly. Mason agreed to step down from his VAR role shortly after. Whatever way you look at it, that is an unforgivable VAR error. Arsenal went on to finish just five points behind Manchester City that season. 

2) Tottenham 2-1 Liverpool: September 2023 

When you are fighting for the title, every point matters. However, many Liverpool fans still feel they were cheated out of one, or maybe even three, at the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium in 2023. After going down to ten men following a Curtis Jones red card, Liverpool seemed to have taken an unlikely lead when Luis Diaz beat the offside trap to slam home the game’s opening goal. Or had he? The linesman on the day flagged for offside and it was eventually cleared by the Premier League VAR team at Stockley Park. There was just one problem, the VAR misunderstood which on-field decision had been given and accidentally confirmed the offside when he meant to confirm the goal. Liverpool went on to lose the game 2-1 to a 96th-minute own goal after going down to nine men. It remains one of the worst VAR decisions ever. 

PGMOL had to release a statement later that evening saying: "The goal by Luis Diaz was disallowed for offside by the on-field team of match officials. This was a clear and obvious factual error and should have resulted in the goal being awarded through VAR intervention. However, the VAR failed to intervene." 

1) Sheffield United 0-0 Aston Villa: June 2020 

Although it was technically a goal-line technology controversy rather than VAR, we couldn’t hand the top spot to anything apart from the Sheffield United goal that never was. Goal-line tech has worked almost perfectly since its implementation in 2014 and many still consider it to be one of the most effective modern changes to football. The premise is simple – if the entire ball goes over the entirety of the line, the referee is informed via a buzz on their watch.  

In June 2020, no such buzz occurred when Aston Villa keeper Orjan Nyland appeared to catch the ball from a free-kick and carry it back over his own goal line. Despite VAR being in use on the day, it was not used to double-check the goal-line technology controversy. Aston Villa ended up earning a 0-0 draw, and that point was enough to keep them up as Bournemouth and Watford were relegated instead. When you look at the trajectory Villa have gone on since then, it feels like an extremely impactful sliding doors moment. To this day, even five years on, it remains one of the worst VAR decisions of all time.