Top 10 Unexpected Defeats in Soccer History 

The scoreboard during the Brazil 1-7 Germany match at the 2014 World Cup semi-finals. (Photo by imago sportfotodienst)

Football is the most popular sport in the world for many different reasons. One is the fact that it is relatively simple to understand. Another is that its low-scoring nature produces shock results more often than other sports. 

We see surprise outcomes in football on almost a weekly basis, but there are certain results that really make people sit up and take notice.  

The 10 unexpected defeats we have picked out in this article sent shockwaves through the world of football, with the losing team taking some time to recover. 

10. PSV 10-0 Feyenoord (2010) 

There are three big clubs in the Netherlands: Ajax, PSV and Feyenoord. Between them those three sides have won 76 Eredivisie titles, compared to 57 for all the other champions combined. Matches between any two members of the trio tend to be tight and tense affairs. 

Not so much when PSV met Feyenoord in 2010, however. The latter were in poor form heading into this game, having won only two of their nine matches so far that season. They arrived at the Philips Stadion in a lowly 15th place in the Eredivisie table, so PSV began the match as clear favourites. 

The fact that Feyenoord lost was not overly surprising. But the scoreline certainly was: this was the worst thrashing inflicted on the club in its entire history.  

A red card in the first half did not help, but PSV were only 2-0 up at the interval. Feyenoord completely collapsed thereafter, conceding eight goals in the second period to leave their supporters distraught. It was an extraordinary outcome that no one could have predicted beforehand. 

9. Greece 1-0 Portugal (2004) 

Portugal cannot say they were not warned. In the opening game of Euro 2004, the hosts were stunned by Greece in what they assumed would be a walkover. Despite a late Cristiano Ronaldo consolation, Portugal suffered a 2-1 defeat to get their campaign off to the worst possible start. 

When the same two teams met again in the final, Luiz Felipe Scolari’s side were expected to make amends. Portugal had grown into the tournament, and although Greece had upset France and Czech Republic in earlier rounds, they could not match their opponents’ quality right across the pitch. 

Yet what Greece did have was a tactical plan, a ferocious team spirit and some good players of their own. They were a defensive side under Otto Rehhagel, leading to some criticism from the purists, but it was hard not to admire their discipline, preparation and intelligence. 

The only goal of the game was scored by Angelos Charisteas in the 57th minute. Try as they might, Portugal could not find an equaliser. After a third clean sheet on the bounce, Greece were champions of Europe against all odds. 

8. Barcelona 1-4 Metz (1984) 

Barcelona began the 1984/85 season as one of the favourites to win the Cup Winners’ Cup. At the very least Terry Venables’ side, who went on to win the La Liga title that campaign, were expected to reach the latter stages without too much difficulty. 

No one felt the need to deviate from that prediction after Barcelona beat Metz 4-2 away from home in the first leg of their first-round clash. The French side themselves must have arrived at the Camp Nou for the return fixture more in hope than expectation. 

Yet what followed was one of the most remarkable results in the history of European competition. Not only did Metz beat Barcelona on their own turf, they did so by the three-goal margin they needed to advance to the second round. 

Barcelona actually took the lead on the night, extending their aggregate advantage to 5-2. But Metz somehow hit back with four goals of their own to leave the Camp Nou crowd dumbstruck. 

7. England 1-2 Iceland (2016) 

In many ways Iceland were the story of the European Championship in 2016. They became the smallest ever country to qualify for the competition that year after finishing ahead of Turkey and the Netherlands in their group. That alone was a phenomenal achievement. 

Iceland had no interest in simply making up the numbers in France, though. They drew 1-1 with both Portugal and Hungary in their first two games, then beat Austria 2-1 to book their place in the knockout phase. 

The round of 16 brought them a dream tie: a meeting with England, one of European football’s heavyweights. Yet it would also surely mark the end of Iceland’s participation in the tournament. That feeling was only strengthened when Wayne Rooney broke the deadlock early on. 

However, the lesson of the previous few years was to never write Iceland off. Ragnar Sigurdsson equalised almost immediately, before Kolbeinn Sigthorsson put the minnows 2-1 up in the 18th minute. England froze and Iceland stood strong, leading to one of the greatest upsets of all time. 

6. Uruguay 2-1 Brazil (1950) 

The script was written. Brazil had never won a World Cup before they hosted the tournament for the first time in 1950, stepping in where European countries could not after the devastation of the Second World War. 

The World Cup used an unusual format this year. Instead of a knockout stage, there were in effect two group phases. Brazil strolled through to the second one, where they promptly thumped Sweden 7-1 and Spain 6-1. 

The Selecao therefore only needed to draw with Uruguay in the final match to be crowned world champions. To say the hosts were confident would be an understatement. More than one local newspaper declared victory the day before the game. Before kick-off, the mayor of Rio de Janeiro heralded the players as “champions” with “no rivals in the entire hemisphere”. 

Big mistake. Brazil took the lead shortly after half-time, but Uruguay turned the match on its head via goals from Juan Alberto Schiaffino and Alcides Ghiggia, not so much upsetting the apple cart as obliterating it. As the Uruguayans celebrated, Brazil mourned. 

5. Videoton 1-0 Manchester United (1985) 

Manchester United were mostly underwhelming in the league during Ron Atkinson’s tenure between 1981 and 1986, but they were much more impressive in cup competitions. The Red Devils won two FA Cups under Atkinson, and for a while it looked like they had an excellent chance of going all the way in the 1984/85 edition of the UEFA Cup. 

After beating Dundee United in the previous round, the Red Devils were handed what looked like a kind draw for the quarter-finals, avoiding the likes of Inter and Real Madrid to be paired with Videoton, a largely unknown Hungarian side who failed to win more than half of their league fixtures that season. 

United only won the first leg 1-0, but that was thought to be good enough even with a trip to Hungary to come. Yet the Red Devils were poor in the reverse fixture, and a goal from Geza Wittmann forced extra time.  

There were no more strikes in the additional 30 minutes of play, but Videoton triumphed in the penalty shoot-out. It remains one of the most unexpected defeats in Manchester United’s history. 

4. Calais 3-1 Bordeaux (2000) 

The Coupe de France is a wonderful tournament. It is open to all amateur and professional clubs in France, including those based in the overseas departments and territories. Every year teams from places like Reunion, Guadeloupe and Martinique take part in the competition. 

There have also been some memorable upsets pulled off by teams from the mainland, none more so than Calais’ run to the final in 2000. A fourth-tier amateur team at the time, they fought their way past Lille, Langon-Castet, Cannes and Strasbourg to reach the last four. 

Bordeaux, the reigning French champions at the time, stood in their way. But the overwhelming favourites could not find a way past Calais’ resolute rearguard in 90 minutes. The minnows then scored three times in extra time to win 3-1 and book their place in the final. 

“We have written one of the most beautiful pages in French football history,'' said Calais coach Ladislas Lozano, whose side went on to suffer a respectable 2-1 defeat by Nantes in the final. 

3. Brazil 1-7 Germany (2014) 

At times at the 2014 World Cup, it seemed like the hosts Brazil were riding a giant wave of emotion. The home crowds sang the national anthem a cappella before matches. On more than one occasion, players were seen crying before, during and after games. 

For a while it worked. Brazil beat Chile on penalties in the round of 16, then saw off Colombia in the quarter-finals. Neymar was injured in that match and Thiago Silva picked up a yellow card that ruled him out of the semis, but Brazil were still reasonably confident of getting the better of Germany. 

As it turned out, the Selecao fell to the occasion. Thomas Muller opened the scoring relatively early on. Then, in perhaps the most jaw-dropping six-minute period in the history of the game, Germany put the ball in the back of the net four more times. 

Five-nil down at half-time, Germany scored twice more after the interval to make it seven heaven. Oscar scored for the home team in the 90th minute, but by then their ignominy was long complete. 

2. Real Madrid 1-2 Sheriff Tiraspol (2021) 

It would be wrong to say that Sheriff Tiraspol were underestimated going into this Champions League game in 2021, for that would imply that they were estimated at all. This was Real Madrid’s first European game at the renovated Estadio Santiago Bernabeu for 18 months and the Spanish side were determined to put on a show. 

The match was certainly worth watching, but not for the reason Madrid intended. Sheriff, who had beaten Shakhtar Donetsk 2-0 a couple of weeks earlier, took a shock lead through Jasurbek Yakhshiboev midway through the first half. 

When Karim Benzema restored parity from the penalty spot in the 65th minute, it looked like normal service had resumed. But Madrid could not find the vital third goal, despite dominating the possession and shot count. 

Then came the sucker punch, as a stunning individual strike from Sebastien Thill in the 90th minute gave Moldovan side Sheriff their greatest ever victory. "We have created a miracle,” said their manager Turiy Vernydub. 

1. United States 1-0 England (1950) 

The most unexpected defeat in the history of the sport befell England in 1950. The Three Lions were making their World Cup debut that summer, having decided to sit out the 1934 and 1938 editions. But while they had no pedigree in the tournament itself, there was no doubt that England were among the strongest sides on the planet. 

As for the United States, they were rank outsiders heading into the competition in Brazil. Their team was composed of semi-professionals - the players’ other occupations included a teacher, a hearse driver and a dishwasher - and was hastily assembled before the big kick-off. 

The pressure was entirely off the USA, then, with England expected to make light work of their opponents. Instead, Joe Gaetjens scored the only goal of the game in the 38th minute to leave the Three Lions - and the rest of the world - shell-shocked. 

The result was so unbelievable that a newspaper back in Britain reported the scoreline as 10-0 in England’s favour, assuming that the ‘1-0’ sent to them was a typo.