NFL Rivalries That Define the League

Latavius Murray during the Steelers vs Ravens game at Heinz Field in 2021. (Photo by Jason Pohuski/CSM/Sipa USA)

When the NFL schedule for the new season is released each year, there are some games that fans will automatically look for before all others.

These rivalries can be based on geography or history, forged in the fires of ferocious games and controversial outcomes… and, of course, the bitter recriminations that followed.

For fans of the NFL teams involved, winning games against these opponents are just as important as landing divisional titles or, in the most extreme cases, making it to the Super Bowl.

These are the rivalries that add great energy and anticipation to the seasonal schedule… American football just wouldn’t be the same without them.

Pittsburgh Steelers vs Baltimore Ravens

“The coaches hate each other. The players hate each other. There's no calling each other after the game and inviting each other out to dinner. They don't like us, and we don't like them. There's no need to hide it. They know it, and we know it.”

This quote1 from former Steelers’ star Hines Ward sums up the rivalry between Pittsburgh and the Baltimore Ravens rather nicely.

All of the ingredients are in place for one of the hottest rivalries in modern American football history – remember, the Ravens weren’t even established until 1996, so this is very much a war for the contemporary age.

Around 250 miles separates the two cities. That may seem like it’s a long way, but in American sporting terms it can be defined as a local derby. And then you have the competitive element: these are, historically, two of the strongest teams in the AFC North – they’ve won an incredible 18 out of the last 24 editions, no less.

And then there’s the playing styles. You know when two people get on each other’s nerves because they’re so similar? That’s basically what you get with the Ravens and the Steelers, who are renowned for their hard-hitting, defensive styles.

This is a rivalry made real by the concussions, the bruises and the wounds of battles gone before and those which are surely yet to come.

All good stories need a protagonist or two, and this Ravens vs Steelers rivalry has had plenty of those over the years. Hines Ward, as you can tell from that quote published earlier, has been a key wind-up merchant in the back story, but he met his match in former Ravens ace Terrell Suggs, who once suggested that there was a ‘bounty’ on Ward’s head.

Suggs, faced by an NFL disciplinary committee, backtracked and said that his words were made in jest. And yet, deep down, it was a comment that was befitting this most passionate of rivalries. 

New York Giants vs Philadelphia Eagles

New York and Philadelphia have one of those rivalries that transcends sport and informs other areas of life, such as music and even food.

The Giants and the Eagles, as two of the cities’ key sporting franchises, shoulder the burden of that enmity – and have done since the 1930s.

Their rivalry went on to be forged over the next two decades, with first the Giants and then the Eagles becoming some of the most dominant forces in the NFL. When they met in the 30s and 40s, there was typically more at stake than just local bragging rights.

NFL historians still talk about ‘The Hit’ today. In 1960, the Eagles’ Chuck Bednarik hit the Giants’ Frank Gifford with a tackle that bordered on physical assault. It was a clean and legitimate hit, so Bednarik escaped punishment, but Gifford was not so lucky.

He was knocked unconscious and had to be stretchered from the field, spending ten days in hospital after being diagnosed with severe concussion.

Load up a rundown of the biggest hits in American football via your favourite media outlets and Bednarik’s bashing of Gifford will typically be high up on the list.

It’s moments like that which encapsulate rivalries and build a distaste that can last for years thereafter, and even in this new era the likes of Eli Manning and Saquon Barkley have referred to the ill feeling that still remains between the two franchises – Barkley famously leaving the Giants for the Eagles in 2024 in a move that, shall we say, did not go down very well.

Mets vs Phillies. Flyers vs Rangers. Giants vs Eagles. The bitterness between New York and Philadelphia runs deep, and one of those unmissable NFL traditions – even for neutral fans that don’t have any skin in the game – is to sit down and watch these enduring rivals do battle each season out on the football field.

New England Patriots vs New York Jets

Although the on-field fortunes of these two franchises have fluctuated over the years, their resentment towards each other has remained an absolute constant throughout.

And like all good NFL rivalries, the animosity between the New England Patriots and the New York Jets is both geographic and historic.

Whether it’s the Yankees vs the Red Sox or the Celtics vs the Knicks, the battles between the representatives of Beantown and the Big Apple are famous across sport – in fact, the rivalry extends beyond just sport, but that’s another story for another day.

The Pats and the Jets continue in that fine lineage, waging war against one another each season in AFC East – in fact, they’ve met more than 130 times, making this one of football’s most storied rivalries.

From the AFL days to Monday Night Madness, when raucous fans were arrested and handcuffed to chain link fences, this is a conflict that dates back decades.

In 1997, there was the infamous ‘tapping up’ incident, when the Patriots accused the Jets of approaching head coach Bill Parcells for their vacant position. After a legal battle ensued, eventually Parcells moved to New York – taking his assistant Bill Belichick with him.

Whatever happened to Belichick?

Well, in 1999 he delivered his infamous ‘I resign as HC of the NYJ’ resignation letter on a napkin before telling the press he was quitting the Jets1.

After weeks of legal wrangling, Belichick was revealed as the new head coach of the Patriots – with whom he would land six Super Bowl titles in the greatest dynasty in NFL history.

But he and the Jets would experience more controversy after Belichick was accused of spying on the New York franchise 2007, using staff members to film their defensive signals2.

Belichick later admitted his guilt and was fined $500,000, while further deepening the long rivalry between the two teams.

Since then there have been brawls, fall-outs and other accusations of wrongdoing; continuing the Pats vs the Jets as one of the biggest NFL rivalries in the game.

Cincinnati Bengals vs Cleveland Browns

The origin story of this rivalry, known as the ‘Battle of Ohio’ is one of the most interesting in football.

You may have heard of Paul Brown, the Hall of Fame coach who won three NFL Champi onships in the 1950s with the Browns; the franchise that was named after him.

Towards the end of his tenure in Cleveland, Brown began to lose the respect of his players, who were growing tired of his dictatorial approach to play-calling. In 1961, Art Modell acquired a controlling stake in the Browns as owner, and quickly he and Brown also began to experience a difference in opinion.

In January 1963, Modell fired his previously all-conquering head coach. Scorned and desperate to prove himself once more, Brown went on to help form the Cincinnati Bengals, acting as both investor and – until 1975 – head coach.

He could not replicate the successes he had in Cleveland, but Brown was still able to lay the foundations for a franchise that has since made three appearances in the Super Bowl – losing all of them.

Brown was later inducted in the pro football Hall of Fame and even has a statue in his honour in Ohio.

With such close links both in history and geography, the rivalry between the Browns and the Bengals remains fierce to this day, despite neither franchise particularly setting the world alight in recent times.

Chicago Bears vs Green Bay Packers

This is one of the oldest and most historic football matchups, first played way back in 1921.

The Bears and the Packers have played each other more than 200 times since, and have gone on to meet at least once in 103 of the last 105 seasons.

As football rivalries go, it’s perhaps not as fierce as the battlelines drawn in other famous NFL contests, but there is still a unique feel to games between Chicago and Green Bay owing to their lengthy history.

These are two of the most decorated franchises in American football history, which only serves to add to the animosity, and these are teams that have been blessed with many a feisty character over the years – this is a fight for bragging rights that extends way beyond state boundaries.

Sources

1 – https://www.baltimorebeatdown.com/2011/11/4/2537012/ravens-steelers-true-rivals

2 - https://www.patriotshalloffame.com/the-agreement-that-brought-bill-belichick-to-new-england-20-years-ago/

3 - https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2015/sep/08/report-patriots-spied-on-rivals-40-times-and-stole-play-sheets-from-locker-rooms